• About
  • Advertise
  • Contact us
The Trending Buzz
  • Home
  • News
  • Marketing
  • Technology
  • Personal Finance
  • Lifestyle
    • Relationships
    • Health and Fitness
  • Entertainment
    • Sports
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Marketing
  • Technology
  • Personal Finance
  • Lifestyle
    • Relationships
    • Health and Fitness
  • Entertainment
    • Sports
No Result
View All Result
The Trending Buzz
No Result
View All Result
Home Entertainment

Three Reasons Why Joaquin Phoenix’s Joker Pales in Comparison with Heath Ledger’s Joker

by Rahul Sharma
April 13, 2020
in Entertainment
Joaquin Phoenix Joker
26
SHARES
853
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Whatsapp

Joker was undoubtedly one of the most successful movies of 2019 – both in terms of box office performance and critical acclaim. Joaquin Phoenix’s portrayal of Arthur Fleck, the mentally ill loner who goes on to terrorize Gotham city, was met with universal acclaim – deservingly so.

The problem, however, is that many fans – and even some critics – have gone overboard and declared that Joaquin Phoenix’s version of the Joker is better than Heath Ledger’s version, which in my opinion is blasphemy.

As good as Phoenix was, he could never overshadow Ledger, for reasons I intend to discuss in detail in this article. Just to be clear – this is not a comparison of Phoenix’s performance with Ledger’s performance. They both excelled in their roles. This is a comparison of the character they played.

Without further ado, let us get started with the comparison.

Scary Joker vs. Wimpy Joker

The first and perhaps the most obvious difference you can notice between Ledger’s Joker and Phoenix’s Joker is that the former is a menace and the latter is a joke – quite literally.

Ledger’s Joker was virtually a force of nature – unpredictable, uncontrollable, and dangerous. Phoenix’s Joker, on the other hand, is a timid clown who is incapable of scaring anyone – leave along terrorize an entire city.

Take, for instance, the scene in The Dark Knight where the Joker meets the mob bosses and suggests that they kill the Batman. He walks into the lion’s den all by himself, kills a henchman without breaking a sweat, and casually reveals that he has strapped himself with enough explosives to blow them all to kingdom come.

The high point of Phoenix’s Joker, on the other hand, is where he takes out a few rich bankers who bully him on a subway. Paul Kersey did it 40 years ago and he looked a lot meaner and menacing than Phoenix’s Joker can ever hope to.

Agent of Chaos vs. Victim of Circumstances

Ledger’s Joker, to put it simply, was an agent of chaos. He blew up things and killed people because – in his own words – he wanted to introduce a little anarchy into the establishment. He was not a rebel, he was not an anti-hero, he did not belong to any sect, and he was not driven by any ideology. He did not even have a plan. He was, again, in his own words, a dog chasing a car.

The only thing that Ledger’s Joker believed in was the evil lurking inside every man. He genuinely believed that any man, no matter how good or moral he is, can be forced to embrace his dark side, under the right circumstances. That is why he relentlessly targeted Harvey Dent and the Batman, who were the two symbols of human goodness in Gotham.

It is also why he could not be reasoned with, bullied, or threatened. When the Batman tries to scare him, the Joker simply laughs in his face and says that he has got nothing to threaten him with. Simply put, he was a force of nature. He represented chaotic evil in all its glory.

Phoenix’s Joker, on the other hand, is a victim of circumstances. He was not born evil and he tries his very best to be a good son, a good neighbor, and a good citizen, until circumstances force him to break the law and commit crimes.

Think about it.

If social service programs had not been cut in Gotham and if Arthur Fleck still had access to his psychiatrist and his medications, would he have gone off the rails and turned into the Joker?

If he had not gotten fired from his job, would he have turned into the Joker?

If the single mom – whom he fantasized about – had shown any interest in him, would he have turned into the Joker?

If Murray Franklin had not made fun of him, would he have turned into the Joker?

If his mom had not lied about him being the son of Thomas Wayne, would he have turned into the Joker?

The answer to all these questions is ‘not likely’. This is precisely why Phoenix’s Joker could never generate a sense of dread and panic among the citizens of Gotham like Ledger’s Joker did.

In other words, in order to stop someone like Ledger’s Joker, you have to take extraordinary measures – like spying on an entire city, which the Batman did. You have to burn the whole forest down, in the words of Alfred.

To stop someone like Phoenix’s Joker, all you have to do is increase funding to social service programs and get him a primetime slot on national TV. In no time, he would be raising a family in the suburbs, driving a Prius, and paying his taxes like a model citizen.

The Problem of an Origin Story

Heath Ledger Joker
flickr.com / morningmagician/

One of the things that made Ledger’s Joker such a fascinating character is the lack of an origin story. Where was he originally from? How did he become the Joker? How did he get those scars? Nobody had a clue.

The mysterious part made Ledger’s Joker that much more terrifying, as you had no idea who he was or what he was capable of doing. In a philosophical sense, it is even more fascinating because here is a man who has transcended his past. He does not care to talk about his past and deliberately lies about it, because he does not care who he was. He only cares about what he is now.

Arthur Fleck’s life, on the other hand, is an open book. He does not shy away from admitting that he lives with his mother or that he has mental illness. It makes him relatable – he could be any one of the millions of Americans who are struggling with mental disorders and are hopelessly pessimistic about their future. It takes the allure and mystique away from the character.

So, there you have it folks. These are the reasons why, as much as I enjoyed Phoenix’s version of the Joker, I never found it better than – or even as good as – Ledger’s Joker. What do you think?

 

Tags: Heath LedgerJoaquin PhoenixJokerLedger JokerPhoenix Joker
Share17Tweet11Send
Rahul Sharma

Rahul Sharma

I am Rahul Sharma a freelance Creative Writer. The work that I do is the love of my life. I am not just passionate about Trending and Tech Stuff but in fact I am totally into it. The idea and conception of this blog came to me as a part of my quest to find the latest updates going around the web. Follow me on Twitter @Im_RahulSharma

Related Posts

Raj Jagatsingh Featuring Ragi Jan2

Om Namah Shivay: A Magnificent Music Video by Raj Jagatsinh Featuring Ragi Jani

by The Trending Buzz
May 19, 2023
0

Raj Jagatsinh, a renowned writer and director from Gujarat, has collaborated with the talented Gujarati actor Ragi Jani for his...

Muskaan Bamne music video Amit Mishra's song

Muskaan Bamne debuts In Music Video With Amit Mishra’s Song

by The Trending Buzz
February 26, 2023
0

Muskaan Bam who played the role of Pakhi in the popular TV show Anupama made her debut in the music...

Shweta Mehta was spotted roaming the streets of Australia in a pink outfit

Shweta Mehta was spotted roaming the streets of Australia in a pink outfit

by The Trending Buzz
December 12, 2022
0

Beautiful actress Shweta Mehta, who is known as the winner of Roadies 15, is currently spending her days in Australia...

Load More

Follow us

Tweets by TheTrendingBuzz
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Racist Stereotypes

Modern Family Is Not So Modern! It is Filled with Clichés and Racist Stereotypes

July 2, 2018
Haunted by Your Ex

What to Do If You Are Haunted by Your Ex? New Trend in Dating

March 13, 2020

The Best Kept Secret Small Business Ideas That Can Make Serious Money

June 21, 2022
Cloud Storage Services Startups

The 5 Best Cloud Storage Services for Startups in 2019

April 15, 2019
Top Secrets of Maximizing Your Website’s Value before Selling It

Top Secrets of Maximizing Your Website’s Value before Selling It

13

How To Make Yourself Smarter With Delicious Food

5
Partnerships

Introducing The Eighth ‘P’ In Marketing: Why Partnerships Are Now A Vital Piece Of The Puzzle

4

Cool Summer Foods and What to Do with Them

2
Apps For Gen Z In 2023

The Best On-demand Apps For Gen Z In 2023

June 23, 2023
Raj Jagatsingh Featuring Ragi Jan2

Om Namah Shivay: A Magnificent Music Video by Raj Jagatsinh Featuring Ragi Jani

May 19, 2023
The Most Useful Websites For A Job Search In 2023

The Most Useful Websites For A Job Search In 2023

April 16, 2023
Muskaan Bamne music video Amit Mishra's song

Muskaan Bamne debuts In Music Video With Amit Mishra’s Song

February 26, 2023

At The Trending Buzz, we create and curate premium news content to keep our readers informed about the key happenings around the world.
Contact us: rahul@thetrendingbuzz.com

Categories

  • Home
  • Marketing
  • Technology
  • Personal Finance
  • Lifestyle
  • Relationships
  • Health and Fitness
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Press Releases
  • Tips & Tricks
  • Uncategorized

Newsletter



  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Who is Behind The Trending Buzz
  • Press Releases
  • Privacy Policy

COPYRIGHT © 2020 THE TRENDING BUZZ. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Marketing
  • Technology
  • Personal Finance
  • Lifestyle
    • Relationships
    • Health and Fitness
  • Entertainment
    • Sports

Copyright © 2020 The Treanding Buzz. All Rights Reserved.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.